In his regular column for the Daily Nation Co-Editor Nic Cheeseman joins forces with Co-Editor SJ Cooper-Knock to explore the key challenges in African Higher Education: Investment, academic freedom, accessibility and inclusivity. This column marks the launch of DiA’s Decolonising the University Reading List, which can be found here.
The #FeesMustFall student protests in South Africa have highlighted the many challenges facing university education in Africa. Not least, that African universities are often under funded and under staffed. One consequence of this is that African students get a raw deal — in some cases, they pay higher fees than their counterparts in Europe, but get less in return. This is just one of a number of global knowledge inequalities that need to be eradicated.
Nelson Mandela once argued that ‘education is the most powerful weapon, which you can use to change the world’. This sentiment is echoed by governments and citizens across the world: Education can help us to better understand the world around us and our place in it, equipping us to push for good social, economic and political change.
Higher education across Africa is booming. The number of students enrolled in tertiary education has increased from fewer than 200,000 in 1970 to around 10 million today. Universities in Kenya, Morocco, Nigeria, South Africa, and Uganda are leading lights from the continent in the 2016 Times Higher Education rankings.
But, as thousands of protesting students across South Africa have highlighted over the last ten days, education does not always live up to its promise. Instead, universities can serve to reinforce the inequalities and injustices that they should be helping to correct.
Listen to the voices of university students, lecturers and administrators across Africa and you will hear four core challenges that tertiary education needs to tackle.
Investing in Higher Education
Governments invest in what they value. In order for further education to receive the investment it desperately needs, governments must recognise that it is both inherently valuable as well as being essential for training the next generation of Africans to contribute to the social, economic, and political life of the continent. That means investing in the arts and humanities, as well as investing in science and engineering.
Currently, investment in African universities is lacking, and the quality of education is suffering as a result. While African governments now invest around US$2,000 of public funding per student (more than the average for developing countries), this follows decades of underinvestment in which drives for education focused on primary and secondary learning.
Unless investment increases to keep pace with growing enrolment numbers, African universities will continue to be severely stretched. At present, the average number of students per lecturer in sub-Saharan Africa is twice as high as the international average. In Kenya, studies recorded up to 64 students per lecturer.
High quality teaching and learning environments are well-resourced ones: African governments must invest if they want to reap the rewards of a highly educated citizenry.
Protecting Academic Freedom
Academics thrive when they are given the liberty to pursue original and timely issues, and the space to provide critical analysis. Their work, in turn, challenges society to grow and improve. Currently 25 per cent of African states constitutionally protect academic freedom. Documents like the Dar es Salaam Declaration on Academic Freedom and Social Responsibility of Academics, and the Kampala Declaration on Intellectual Freedom and Social Responsibility are also encouraging. However, in many countries there is still much room for improvement.
In countries like the DRC, institutional autonomy is jeopardised by appointment procedures: The president is able to appoint the university rector, who in turn appoints deans, vice-deans and heads of departments. Government ministerial regulations also shape what programmes are offered, and how students are recruited. In addition to stifling academic freedom, such measures drive students to seek education outside their state’s borders, depriving it of their skills and forfeiting the contribution they may have otherwise made to its development.
Even where such institutional control is not formally in place, academic freedom can be constrained by the broader political restrictions on freedom of speech, and the government’s propensity to marginalise, arrest, or threaten those who criticise the regime.
Ensuring Accessible Education
The most obvious barrier for many would-be students is financial. As thousands of South African students in #FeesMustFall protests testified, fees play a large role in determining whether many learners across the continent can enrol or complete their education. Currently, it costs R64,500 to complete a first year Bachelor of Medicine at the University of Cape Town. It is, therefore, unsurprising that 55 per cent of students who enrol in South African universities, will not graduate.
But access is not a purely financial issue: There are many other barriers from poor primary and secondary education to gender discrimination that can make university education effectively unattainable. Across sub-Saharan Africa, for example, female students currently constitute just 38 per cent of the numbers enrolled in higher education.
Creating Inclusive Education
Promoting inclusive education means ensuring curriculums include the voices of marginalised or historically marginalised populations; ensuring the academy speaks to and with people, not just about them; enabling classrooms to be spaces in which all voices are heard and valued; and creating faculties that recruit and promote staff fairly and inclusively.
The recent protests and conversations that have surrounded #FeesMustFall #RhodesMustFall and #CanaanStudies suggest that universities in Africa are still marginalising the voices that should be at the centre of their teaching, learning, and research. Thanks to the persistence of protestors, there are some hopeful signs of change within South African universities, marking a step forward on a long road to transformation.
To facilitate more inclusive discussions at the university level, we also need to explore how knowledge on Africa is produced and published. Currently, far more literature is produced within African studies by non-African scholars than by those from the continent. This needs to change. Again, change is not easy. While journals like African Affairs (co-edited by Nic Cheeseman) hold writing workshops in African universities and offer prizes to encourage and celebrate African writers, they rarely publish issues that feature a majority of African authors.
Some of the reasons for this gap take us back to the issue of funding. Many African lecturers are hopelessly overstretched teaching large class sizes. At the same time, they receive little in the way of admin support or funding to cover the costs of their research.
The recent wave of protests in South Africa is just the latest in a series of efforts by students, scholars and governments across Africa to tackle these challenges.
As academics in the UK, we celebrate these moves forward, stand in solidarity with those who make them, and reflect on the ways in which the tough questions being raised can help to produce a more level playing field.
In this spirit of solidarity we have taken three small steps, and would warmly welcome a broader dialogue with African scholars across the continent for ways to effect larger institutional change.
First, in response to requests from colleagues and friends, we have assembled a ‘Decolonising the University’ reading list, showcasing the vital and path-breaking research on Africa by African scholars, which is available here. If you spot anything that we have overlooked, please get in touch and let us know and we will add it to the list.
For more details, check out www.decolonizingtheacademy.wordpress.com.
Finally, we continue to create new scholarships for African students who wish to study at the University of Oxford or the University of Edinburgh. Our hope is to build accessible platforms for African students, contributing to the expanding number of graduate students across the continent, who are already contributing so much to their respective societies. We are incredibly grateful partners such as Mitsui and Co. Ltd, Standard Bank, ENI, DFID, and Canon Collins Trust for generously supporting our universities with these scholarships.
Kenyan readers may be interested to know that the Oxford and Cambridge Society of Kenya has teamed up with the Swire Educational Trust to generously fund a scholarship for a student ordinarily resident in Kenya to read for a one year Master’s course at St Antony’s College. Kenyans who have a strong undergraduate background and have not yet gone on to do a PhD and are interested in studying at Oxford University should apply. Full details can be found at www.africanstudies.ox.ac.uk/scholarships. Similar scholarships are available at Edinburgh University, and can be located at www.ed.ac.uk/student-funding/search-scholarships.
Striving to improve the investment, independence, accessibility and inclusivity of higher education in Africa, and beyond, is as complex as it is crucial. Its success will depend on strong partnerships between academics within and without the continent. These partnerships must embody the changes that we seek: putting at their centre the priorities, voices, and vibrant scholarship of Africa’s outstanding researchers.
Nic, SJ, you raise some really important issues. But for me there’s a bit of a logical flaw in the suggested response. It’s fantastic for African scholars to come and study in Oxford and Edinburgh, and such scholarships have enabled many to lay the foundations of future careers and become part of vital networks. But for African universities to thrive they need to develop their talent at home, so that not only are those excellent scholars studying and learning themselves, but are contributing to the academic life of their departments and institutions and mentoring new students as they do. And of course you could probably afford to fund several scholars in Kenya for the cost of one in Oxford. This is where the split site or joint programmes can be so good – early career researchers remain embedded in the life of their home institutions but spend a year or perhaps to lots of six months abroad. Even better would be for more of that to take place in the region and there are several initiatives designed to enable that within Africa mobility and the development of academic networks that it allows. So I thoroughly agree with you – we need to support the development of African universities. But if we really mean it, we’ve got to be doing more within Africa’s universities – supporting those who are driving change – not just within our own. These are issues we’re tackling at INASP (www.inasp.info) – one simple way for UK or other experienced researchers (and this includes PhDs and postdocs) is our research writing and publishing mentoring and training programme AuthorAID (www.AuthorAID.info)
Thanks for your comment, Jon. I think you’re absolutely right about partnering with African universities, and I don’t think that’s mutually exclusive with scholarships elsewhere. I think the ideal for African scholars (as for all scholars) is that they can have the option of excellent, affordable and accessible education both at home and abroad. I think we can all work within our own institutions and in partnership with others to achieve that goal.
Speaking in the context of Edinburgh, we’ve got loads of partnerships with other universities in Africa and beyond which we find incredibly valuable and exciting, including staff exchanges (for early career and senior scholars), workshops, training courses and summer schools, etc. Our newest partnership programme Security At The Margins – which is starting this week – runs with Wits and provides funding for training, staff exchanges, and partnership research projects over the next three years. Its jointly funded by the ESRC in the UK and the NRF in South Africa.
I look forward to checking out the websites that you referenced. Thanks for your comment! SJ
[…] It is clear that Africa has challenges in education. These challenges do not exist in a vacuum. I link the article below, not because I agree with it in full but because it opens up the conversation and presents ways to address the situation. We need to carefully think about Higher Education in Africa. […]
it is absolutely perfect if us Africans we try to borrow ideas from the western and we firge with ours so as to rhyme with other institutions across the globe…..
We want Francophone too! Please send them in!
It is indeed true that African Universities and with specific context, kenyan institutions of higher learning, have great and real challenges to confront if we have to redeem our education system at higher levels. One aspect not brought out in all the above is the unethical urge for higher papers which negates quality through doctored results at basic education levels, exam leakages which transit unqualified students to several careers and rapid expansion of university settlite campuses to generate income .